E-StoreHome » Ask & Discuss » Fun Zone » Lounge « Back to Discussion
Lounge
Hey all,
I want to have a debate sort of thing between us on this topic-
Mahatma Gandhi V/s Bhagat Singh
How many of U think that Mahatma Gandhi's share in helping India to get freedom was more than Bhagat Singh's? Or vice versa?
How many of U believe that ''ahimsa'' is the right tool to snatch our independence from foreign hands? Or do U think that Bhagat Singh's revolutionary ideas are the right tool?
PLZ share with all of us, whom wud U have chosen as ur ideal if U were present in the era of Indian Freedom struggle? And WHY??
P.S.plz dont give replies like ''both are gr8'' or ''both played an imp. role in our freedom struggle''. I agree with this but still, plz choose one who U feel wud have been ur ideal.
Comments (48)
I actually had participated in a real life debate about extremist vs satyagraha and i remember one person saying
"there is a thin line separating a person practicing satyagraha and when a person tries to be sticky, for us the latter can never be realised, consider urself to be of any other nation n ull realise how far the father of our nation had reached"
do u hold the British responsible for what happened in our pre 1947 period ?
do u have hatred towards the english now ? i have heard people say(for instance), "i'd rather have a maruti 800 than a rolls royce becuz its from the people who snatched our soil" n stuff
dun u think India is responsible ?
wudnt India do the same if it were a superpower ?
it was mr bhagat u bought the common segment to show there mutiny britishers din stop eating or sleepin when mr gandhi was on his satyagraha but indeed turned restless on wat bhagat did though he also din eat for 55 days but bfore dat he had changed the picture of common segment!
before d second round table conf..........if gandhi ji wished he cud have saved bhagat.....coz he really had mass before him n dats why british agreed to him........but he din do so.....coz bhagat singh was a rebel!........besides..........i feel gandhi ji delayed freedom......india was a big mass........oilence wud have done it easily............ppl died in gandhian way as well..........so i say...bhagat singh was not very plaaned.....n gandhin rules r gud personally but not to carry a revolution................so i support....finally bhagat........actually none of dem.............sc bose nehru(he was initially a rebel).....
yaar tarin....
lol....finally sumthing interesting...
yeah after that "god's xistence " issue...dis 1's the oder 1 we used 2 discuss at scool..highly controversial..but highly engaging...
and i'd any day go by bhagat singh....any damn day...
coz freedom can never be obtained by getting people standing in rows and getting beaten...its always attained by letting the rulers know...that how much we value and honour freedom and our country...
so bhagat singh by faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrr
and all those who gave their life's for it...
gandhiji was only a person who was our representative to the british..
the diff is like soldiers who fight( bhagat singh , rajguru n sukhdev) ...
and diplomats and politicians who converse and bhuk hartal n stuff...(gandhiji)...
simple theory : lions for lambs..
how can u forget his contribution
of course i dont support gettin beaten up n not raising a hand for self defense
but both gandhi n bhagat singh were extremists as far as there ideologies r considered...... isnt it
so the best said is that one shud be flexible n not extremists
atleast not like gandhi who stopped the powerful non cooperation movement (just for sum chauri chaura movmt......and who was hell bent to his ideologies of non violence)
hahhahaha....
long term / short term......
if bhagat singh wunt have put his llife on stake 4 us , 4 freedom , 4 india...
we wuld be seeing the long term effects stilll...
gandhiji wuld have kept on talking till now...
and me n u..wuld have been serving a bristish now..then talking here...,.....so plzzz grow up....
peace and non- violence has never won any1 nething...
Preparing for IIT-JEE ?
Arihant Revision Package for IIT JEE - Books, Practice Tests + Rank Predictor
@ INR 1,995/-
For Quick Info
Find Posts by Topics
Physics.
TopicsMathematics.
Chemistry.
Biology
Institutes
Parents
Board
Fun Zone
|
|
|
|
|
| 35,229,755 Engineering Questions Attempted |
6,69,530 Visitors Monthly |
79 Engg. Exam Covered |
983 Students Currently Online |
Connect with Us  |
 |
hmmm...
bapuji was too gud
---even stopped a movement coz of chauri chowra incident!
bhagat singhji was a bit impatient
---coz a few bombs jus can neva stop a colonial power---!
i likd SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSEs way---gathered an army!---well equipped
--so dat he cud atleast giv d country a fair chance--nd quicker independence too!
PS: ma 500th post